I think it started on the walk-talks Louie Bacaj and I do, both on Zoom but walking and talking. Every so often, Louie or I would exclaim: this frontier lab is incredible, their ability to see and live in the future is going to crush everybody else. How can anyone compete?
But on another walk, I’d say the opposite: the frontier labs are f*cked. They have no moat. Open-weight models are a tenth of the cost and catching up fast.
I was remarking on these manic swings to Claude. Maybe I was trying to rationalize my attraction to two companies I admire: Anthropic and Cloudflare. I suggested the age old barbell strategy. When in doubt, bet on both sides.
Then the conversation got a bit crazier. We realized the two ends weren’t rivals but a loop, each feeding off the other. My swings weren’t contradictions. Depending on the season, I was just seeing a different part of the loop. It reminded me of the Wintel duopoly, or more recently, the iPhone/Android dance. Maybe every tech boom needs a dance partner.
I’ve always loved Explainer videos, and so with Claude on my screen, we co-created one:
More details at https://chaos.numtot.org/posts/barbell-thesis

A compelling presentation of something very complex, so well done even I could understand it.